New researchTechnical SEO & AI Search · 2027Explore the framework

Soft 404 errors: what they are and how to fix them

Why Google reports pages that return 200 as soft 404s, the usual causes (empty pages, error messages, homepage redirects) and how to find and fix them.

Part of the Crawling & Indexing series. For the full picture, start with Crawling and indexing: how search engines find your pages, and what stops them.

A soft 404 is a page that says one thing to visitors and another to search engines. The visitor sees “Sorry, this page doesn’t exist” or an empty product list; the server says 200 OK. Google notices the contradiction, treats the page as missing, and reports it in Search Console.

This guide covers what triggers soft 404s, why they matter, and how to find and fix them.

What is a soft 404?

Search Console’s Page indexing report defines it: the page “returns a user-friendly ‘not found’ message but not a 404 HTTP response code.” Google’s recommendation is simple: “We recommend returning a 404 response code for truly ‘not found’ pages.”

Google’s HTTP status code documentation adds that pages whose content “suggests an error”, such as “an empty page or an error message”, are shown as soft 404s in Search Console.

What causes soft 404s?

Cause Example
Error pages that return 200 A custom “not found” template served with a 200 status
Empty listings A category or filter combination with no products
Thin placeholder pages “Coming soon”, empty author or tag pages
Mass redirects to an irrelevant page Every removed product redirected to the homepage
Pages that only render with JavaScript, and fail The HTML shell is empty when rendering doesn’t finish

The redirect case surprises people. Google’s site move guidance warns: “Don’t redirect many old URLs to one irrelevant single URL destination, such as the home page of the new site. This can confuse users and might be treated as a soft 404 error.”

Why do soft 404s matter?

  • They aren’t indexed. If a page you want to rank is reported as a soft 404, Google sees it as empty or broken.
  • They waste crawling. Google keeps requesting URLs that add nothing; its crawl budget guide lists soft 404s among the things that waste crawl time. See crawl budget.
  • They hide real problems. A template that renders blank, or an out-of-stock page with no content, shows up here first.

How do you find soft 404s?

In Search Console, the Page indexing report lists URLs Google classified as soft 404. Open a few in URL Inspection and view the page as Google rendered it.

Across the whole site, a crawl finds the pages likely to be classified that way before Google does. In Crawlens:

  • Thin content (under 200 words) flags indexable pages with almost no text, the most common soft 404 pattern.
  • Content depends on JavaScript and Pages that failed to render (with Render JavaScript on) find pages that are empty without scripts.
  • Custom extraction can pull the text your “not found” or “no results” template shows into a column, for example a CSS extractor on the message element, and a custom rule can flag every 200 page that contains it.
  • For redirects, crawl old URLs in URL list mode and check where they land: many URLs redirecting to the homepage is a soft 404 risk. See redirect mapping.

How do you fix them?

Situation Fix
The page really doesn’t exist Return 404 or 410
An empty filter or search result Return 404, or keep it out of the crawl; see faceted navigation
A page that should exist but looks empty Add real content; see thin content
A removed page redirected to the homepage Redirect to a genuine equivalent, or return 404
Content only appears after JavaScript Render it on the server; see JavaScript SEO

A 404 isn’t a penalty. Google’s Page indexing help says “404 responses are not necessarily a problem, if the page has been removed without any replacement.” The problem is a page that claims to exist while saying it doesn’t.

For how soft 404s fit with the other indexing statuses, see the crawling and indexing guide.

Checklist

  • “Not found” template returns a real 404 status
  • Empty filter and search results return 404 or stay out of the crawl
  • No mass redirects of removed pages to the homepage
  • Thin placeholder pages filled, merged or removed
  • Pages render their main content without relying on JavaScript
  • Soft 404s in the Page indexing report reviewed after each fix

Frequently asked questions

What is a soft 404?

A soft 404 is a page that returns a 200 (success) status code but shows a 'not found' message or nearly empty content. Search Console describes it as a page that returns a user-friendly not-found message but not a 404 HTTP response code.

Are soft 404s bad for SEO?

They aren't indexed, so they can't rank, and they cost crawling time without adding anything. When a page you want indexed is reported as a soft 404, it's a sign it looks empty or broken to Google.

Can a redirect cause a soft 404?

Yes. Google warns that redirecting many old URLs to one irrelevant page, such as the homepage, can confuse users and might be treated as a soft 404. Redirect to a genuine equivalent or return 404.

How do I fix a soft 404?

If the page is really gone, make it return 404 or 410. If it should exist, give it real content so it doesn't look empty. If it moved, redirect it to its actual new location.

· Founder, Crawlens

Dien builds Crawlens, a desktop crawler for technical SEO audits, and writes about the checks it runs: crawling, indexing, rendering and Search Console data.

Audit your own site with Crawlens

Crawl, run 70 checks, and see them next to Search Console and Core Web Vitals data.

Download free for Windows